Buttercup Cheese - Great NY Cheddar Cheese and Domestic Cheese

3lb Wheel NY Sharp Cheddar Cheese
Reg Price:
Sale Price:


Most notably known at the CNY Regional Market in Syracuse, New York, Buttercup Cheese has been offering high quality New York State Cheddar Cheese in the Central New York area since 1969.  We have a variety of NY Cheddar Cheese aged from one year to ten years.  These fantastic cheeses are available in 1lb, 5lb, and 10lb blocks.  Also available are 3lb Sharp and X-Sharp Black Wax Cheddar Cheese Wheels.  These make excellent gifts any time of year.

Domestic Cheeses from New York and other areas within the United States.  Choose from cheeses such as American Sliced, Baby Swiss Wheels, Mozzarella, Swiss, Parmesan Cheese Wheels, Goat Cheese Logs, Tofu and much more.

We have Imported Cheeses from all over the world.  Choose from Holland Gouda, Canadian Goat Cheddar, Jarlsberg Swiss Cheese Wheels, Swiss Gruyere, Danish Fontina Cheese Wheels, Blue Cheese Wheels, and Havarti.  There are many more items to enjoy.

If you like flavored cheese Yancy's Fancy™ Cheese from Corfu, New York is sure to please.  Choose from hot cheeses, smoked cheeses, onion, garlic and horseradish.  Whatever your preference It's probably here.
Send someone special a gift box of fantastic cheese, summer sausage, and some of the hottest horseradish and hot mustard on the planet.   If you don't see one you like we can customize one to send to your friend or loved one.

Some miscellaneous items we carry are pictured to the left.  Choose from Pure New York Maple Syrup, Amish Rolled Butter, Creamery Tub Butter, Pepperoni, Croghan Ring Bologna and a lot more.
We gladly accept:
Solution Graphics
Don't have Paypal?
No Problem.